The singing storyteller sensation Sara Bareilles made the most meaningful music video for her song “I Choose You,” which expertly captures the magic of couples becoming engaged.

The singing storyteller sensation Sara Bareilles made the most meaningful music video for her song “I Choose You,” which expertly captures the magic of three couples becoming engaged.
Bareilles takes viewers through the steps of introducing three lucky fans who are planning on proposing to their partners, and to our delighted surprise, she includes a lesbian couple, Andrea Guarnieri and Aly Malm. Amazingly, Bareilles shows up at all three proposals (the soon-to-be betrothed) are blindfolded) and sings for the crowd. Aly’s story of proposing to Andrea with illustrations and fun sayings, in front of their family and friends at the Lowry Beer Garden in Denver, Colo., had us wiping away happy tears.

“It’s all pretty crazy and amazing!,” says Andrea of her and Aly’s April 9 engagement. “We are actually looking at wedding venues tomorrow to begin our search.”
We’ll be following Aly and Andrea’s wedding-planning story and hoping for another Bareilles performance at the women’s wedding. Watch the full video below and weep happy tears of love, friends. Enjoy!
Video and Bareilles photo: Courtesy Sara Bareilles; Andrea and Aly selfie with Sara Bareillis shared with written permission from Andrea Guarnieri.
MOST VIEWED STORIES
- Love Deserves the Spotlight: Explore 2026’s Freshest Wedding Trends and Share Your Proposal Story for A Chance to Win
- Lemon party inspiration from Engage!25 Santa Barbara
- Your 2026 Wedding Planning Playbook: Decoded from the Year’s Trending Google Searches
- Supreme Court Declines to Hear Marriage Equality Case
- From Swipe to Soulmates: How Daniel & Michael Found Love After a Life-Changing Spinal Cord Injury









