Not every gay NYC couple pulls off a double proposal. Then again, not every love story starts with two strangers reaching for the same song on a Nashville jukebox.
Eric Viner and Jordan Wise were strangers in a Nashville honky-tonk when fate — or Fleetwood Mac — intervened.
A Nashville Honky-Tonk and a Fleetwood Mac Moment
“We met by pure chance in a lively Nashville honky-tonk just before New Year’s Eve, both reaching for the same Fleetwood Mac song,” Eric said. “In that moment, surrounded by music and laughter, it felt like the universe had gently nudged us together — and neither of us could have imagined that one shared song would change our lives forever.”
That song was “Landslide,” and it has never stopped playing in their story. The New York City–based couple began dating Dec. 30, 2023. It was a fitting start for two people who met on the eve of a new year.
How This Gay NYC Couple Pulled Off a Double Proposal
By May 2025, they were ready to make it official. Twice.
Jordan went first. He told Eric they were making a quick stop on the rooftop of their NYC building for a photo before heading to a residency party. There was no party. Waiting instead were a live musician, beautiful flowers and, most unforgettably, both of their families gathered to witness the moment.
Eric wasn’t about to let Jordan be the only one who got to pop the question.
From New York to Italy
“Months later, Eric wanted Jordan to experience the magic of being proposed to — and to proclaim his love in return,” Eric said. On a summer vacation in Portofino, Italy, Eric asked Jordan to spend forever together. “It was the perfect, heartfelt moment, full of love, laughter and the kind of joy that comes from knowing you’ve found your person.”
A Harry Winston ring. Ralph Lauren Purple Label looks. It’s the kind of gay couple double proposal NYC love stories are made of — epic and effortless all at once.
A Lifetime Ahead
“What we love most about each other is how completely and utterly we make each other feel seen, safe and cherished,” Eric said. “Together, we love how effortless our love feels, how we can laugh until our cheeks hurt, cry without fear, dream without limits and find joy in the smallest moments.”
As for what lies ahead, they have their eyes on the everyday as much as the milestones.
“We’re most looking forward to building a lifetime together — waking up every day with our best friend, creating a home filled with love, laughter, and support,” Eric said. “We can’t wait to celebrate the big milestones and cherish the quiet, ordinary moments, knowing that no matter what comes our way, we get to face it hand in hand, choosing each other always.”
Eric and Jordan will celebrate their wedding Sept. 26, 2026. Congratulations to the happy couple! 
Search the Equally Wed directory of LGBTQ+ inclusive wedding vendors.
FEATURED LGBTQ+ INCLUSIVE AND QUEER AFFIRMING WEDDING VENDORS
Photographer: Braden Saba
